One more bailout, One Step Closer to Socialism?

Author: Sarah Riordan

“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public’s money.” – Alexis de Tocqueville 

The above quote by de Tocqueville is so frighteningly insightful that it’s hard to believe it was written in 1805.  De Tocqueville’s warning to America is more relevant today than ever before.

Congressman Cazayoux’s new bill, H.R. 7196, is proof that de Tocqueville’s wisdom continues to fall on deaf ears. In this bill, Cazayoux asks Congress to provide financial relief to farmers who have suffered a financial loss due to a natural disaster.  In other words, any farmer who suffers a loss because of flooding, hurricane, a tornado or any combination thereof will be compensated with taxpayer dollars.

Now before we tie in the problems of this bill with de Tocqueville’s quote, I think a basic civics lesson is required.  There is a question all Americans should be able to answer hands down.  That question is simply “where does the government get its money?”  If you couldn’t enthusiastically answer, “From me, the taxpayer,” then quickly go apply for a job and track the amount of hours you put in just to pay the U.S. government.  If you answered the question correctly, then please, continue reading.

In this bill, Congressman Cazayoux wants you and me to underwrite what should be the private enterprise of farming.  Granted, farming is a tough business which, more than just about any other enterprise, is tied at the hip to the weather.  However, farmers know this (or at least they should).  Like any business venture there are risks and although I wish no farmer ill, I also don’t want to be his insurance company.  By the way, speaking of insurance any prudent farmer will purchase his own crop insurance to mitigate possible losses due to weather.  There are plenty of companies which provide this sort of coverage without government involvement.  Do the premiums come from the farmer’s profits?  Of course but it is a cost of doing business in a free market.

The bill also begs the question, “Why just help the farmers?”  Aren’t other people affected by natural disasters?  The Midwest floods every spring, and numerous businesses suffer the damages. Why doesn’t Congress bail them out too?  While we’re at it, why don’t we toss a little cash to everyone whose basement floods in a big storm?  Come to think about it why doesn’t Congress just start providing all the citizens of the US with a guaranteed paycheck so that no one has to worry about the weather or anything else?  Oh, wait a minute . . . that would be Socialism!   

But that’s the point.  As a nation, we’ve accepted that a large portion of the money we earn will go to the government.  Now, to be fair, there are some good reasons for taxes.  For example, we have roads to drive on and the most powerful military in the world.  Both of those are a result of tax dollars and a healthy reason to take a small percentage of each citizen’s paycheck.  However, Congress has grown to think that your hard earned dollars are theirs to redistribute as they see fit.

So why is Casayoux proposing this legislation?  Call me a cynic but bills like H.R.7196, are nothing more than attempts at gaining the support of farmers by dangling in front of them a sum of money to compensate them for their struggles.  This is what makes de Tocqueville’s quote all the more sobering.  Congress is gaining power by promising voter groups the public’s money.  To be perfectly crass, they are buying votes and you and I are paying the bill.